UNC College Students Don’t Understand Free Speech, Re: Tancredo

Last night a mob of student protesters basically chased Colorado Congressman Tom Tancredo out of a speaking engagement at the University of North Carolina. Now, I don’t particularly like Tancredo as a person, agree with his message, or support his policies. But this was just immature and embarrassing.

Trying to drown and block out speech you don’t like isn’t itself an exercise on free speech, as some of these deluded protesters seemed to think. It’s the heckler’s veto: essentially no different in its effect than if the government tried to silence the talk.

And I’ll never really understand the rationale behind what these protesters were trying to accomplish. Tancredo has strong opinions on the issue of state-tuition. Whether those views are “hateful” or not (and I actually don’t agree that they are inherently “hateful” at all, just wrong), people who wanted to hear what he had to say showed up to listen. Those listeners are not passive sheep: they can decide for themselves what they think of Tancredo’s message.

Whether or not Tancredo would have taken questions or engaged in a dialog with people that oppose him is utterly irrelevant. Because the thing is, if pro-immigration and pro-universal-tuition forces want to host a speaker and invite people to come listen, they are perfectly free to do so, anytime they wish. They are free to try and get people to come listen by the force of their own arguments and appeal and advertising. That’s how debate in a democratic society works.

The protesters at one point unfurled a banner reading “No Dialog with Hate.” But no one forced them to be in that room and engage in any sort of dialog in the first place.

And that’s really the key point. What ultimately seems to make these sorts of protesters angry is not Tancredo himself, but the fact that people freely came and chose to listen to him, and not them. It’s those people they wish to punish, and succeeded in punishing. The protesters want attention, but they’re too lazy to invest time and energy drawing a crowd to hear their own views. So they simply hijack Tancredo’s event instead to push their message down the throats of the audience, whether it came to hear them that night or not.



~ by Drew on 2009/04/15.

2 Responses to “UNC College Students Don’t Understand Free Speech, Re: Tancredo”

  1. Freedom of speech. That’s what these “protesters” resent, and the rest of us need to recognize that bullyboy/stormtrooper tactics such as this need to stopped. We can not afford to be passive and allow disruption of guest speakers; we may disagree on a lot of topics, but we must recognize our freedom is threatened by this rabble.

  2. Yep. There’s nothing more ridiculous than the idea that a person speaking, and other people showing up to listen to them speak, is something that it’s other people’s business to shut down, shout down, and silence. If you have something to say, find yourself a venue and say it, and see if you can get people to listen to you. Don’t pretend that barging into a talk and blaring your own message is in any way in line with valuing freedom of speech and expression.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: